This is the first quest in the Travelers quest line which will take you across all the continent of Amalur. In order to become one of them you must first prove yourself by stealing three important and valuable treasures. If you succeed in bringing them back to the Hierophant you will be admitted into their ranks.
Walkthrough
Talk to Grim Onwig outside the north or south entrance to Star Camp. Ask to join the travelers, and he will send you to talk to Crilgarin.
Enter Star Camp, and talk to Crilgarin, who will send you to the Hierophant Shrine.
You are instructed by the Hierophant Shrine to steal three items to prove your worth to the Travelers.
Travel to the Didenhil Inn. Ealfwig Grilricas will be in the back room on the ground floor, and you can pickpocket the Medallion off of him.
There are a few ways to do this without committing a crime, the easiest of which is to wait until he goes to bed, then sneak over to him and swipe the medallion. Alternatively, you can walk behind him and then speak to him, afterwards he will stay facing the back wall. You can then sneak until you are undetected and then lift the medallion.
Also remember that you need to be undetected, not only by Ealfwig, but by everyone in the Inn.
Otherwise, you can just pickpocket it off him while detected and then pay the fine, which is a pittance compared to the quest reward.
Travel to the Haxhi in Dalentarth. This is east of the Star Camp and is very close so is easy to complete first.
Wait a few minutes outside the Chapel. If you are lucky, the monks inside may leave. If not, you will need to be sneaky.
Once inside the chapel, if there are only one or two monks you will be able to hide behind a corner of the Sarcophagus, the detection meter will go down and you will be able to collect the remains undetected. If it is night time and there are three monks, you will not be able to avoid detection, so you must wait and come back when at least one has left.
If you have already learned the Finesse ability Smoke Bomb, simply throw a bomb and collect the remains.
Travel to The Sidhe in Dalentarth or simply travel South East of St. Eadric's Mission in Haxhi where you completed St. Eadric's Remains to the Vorm Lodge. Inside Gunnar Frode will be sitting at a table. The location to the daggers is on a map which is upstairs inside a locked footlocker. There are a couple of ways to get the key:
Firstly, if your sneak is high enough, you can pickpocket Gunnar for his key. Use the key to unlock his footlocker and take the map inside. Afterwards, you can still ask Gunnar about the daggers, but he can no longer help you.
Otherwise, if you have the money to spare, you can simply buy the key off of him. You can even persuade him to sell it at half price, but be warned: every failed attempt at persuasion doubles the price.
Or, if you prefer lock picking, you could just walk up the stairs to the first room on the left, enter stealth mode and wait until the eye meters empty and then pick the lock on the footlocker! Grab the map and you're ready to go.
After retrieving the map it will highlight the location of the Toothpicks, which are hidden out in The Sidhe.
Loot
While completing St. Eadric's Remains, there is some varying loot in the chests on either side of the door. To get these undetected use the same technique and hide behind the table. Watch the monk's movement paterns and when he begings walking towards the door follow him and quickly collect the loot from the chest. Repeat this twice to get everything in both chest. (Note: this only works if there is only one monk inside.)
Alternatively, you can assassinate the monk, and since there are no witnesses, there will be no repercussions. Or you can wait and hope you can manage to get in the chapel while it is empty.
